SubsiMail
Why self-host Pricing Docs Changelog Support FAQ Log in Get started
Log in Get started

← Back to Support

Reply detection isn't marking threads as replied

#80 Resolved
Christopher C. 384 days ago

I can see replies coming into my connected inbox, but the dashboard still shows those contacts as “no reply” and keeps sending follow-ups.

Melissa Rodriguez Staff 384 days ago

This usually happens when the reply lands in a folder our reply-detection isn't scanning — if you have any inbox rules/filters that move replies out of the main inbox (into a separate folder, label, or category) before we can process them, they won't get matched. Can you check whether any filters might be redirecting replies from this campaign, and if so, either disable that filter for this sending address or add an exception for it?

This ticket has been resolved. Its author or SubsiMail staff can reopen it to reply further.

Other tickets

Resolved Session keeps expiring every hour, is that normal?
Jennifer W. 1 reply
Resolved Attachments over a certain size fail to send
David B. 1 reply
Resolved Does the API support custom merge fields?
Jennifer W. 1 reply
Closed DKIM check keeps failing on Namecheap too
Lisa T. 2 replies
Resolved Can I enable two-factor authentication for my account?
Justin C. 1 reply

SubsiMail

The self-hosted alternative to Mailshake.

Documentation Setup guides Changelog Support Pricing Affiliates Terms of Service Privacy Policy Sitemap

Compare

vs. Instantly vs. Smartlead vs. lemlist vs. Apollo

Solutions

For agencies For recruiters

© 2026 SubsiMail.

We use Google Analytics to understand traffic to this site. It only runs if you accept -- see our Privacy Policy.